As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
Concrete water tanks can store a large amount of water for many years, but they also come with important drawbacks. The main disadvantages are their heavy weight, difficult installation, risk of cracking, harder repairs, and the need to manage water quality carefully.
They can work well for large rainwater systems, especially when installed underground or partly buried. However, they are much less flexible than plastic tanks. Before choosing one, consider the site, soil conditions, access for construction equipment, intended water use, and how the tank will be inspected and maintained.
Concrete Water Tanks Are Very Heavy
Weight is one of the biggest disadvantages of a concrete water tank.
Concrete tanks usually require a prepared foundation that can safely support the tank when it is empty and when it is full. Water itself weighs about 8.34 pounds per US gallon, or about 1 kilogram per liter. A large tank therefore places a major load on the ground even before the weight of the concrete is added.
Poor support can contribute to:
- Uneven settling
- Cracks in the tank
- Pipe movement
- Damaged fittings
- Water leaks
The foundation and surrounding soil become especially important with large tanks, buried installations, slopes, or unstable ground.
A qualified contractor or engineer may be needed when structural loading or soil stability is uncertain.
Installation Is More Difficult
Concrete tanks are harder to install than most above-ground plastic tanks.
A precast concrete tank may require a crane, large truck, or other lifting equipment. A poured-in-place tank requires formwork, reinforcement, concrete placement, and enough curing time before the tank can be placed into service.
Installation can also require:
- Excavation
- A suitable access route for heavy equipment
- A properly prepared base
- Drainage around the tank
- Accurate placement of inlet and outlet pipes
- Safe access for future inspection
These requirements can make concrete unsuitable for properties with narrow access, steep terrain, soft soil, or limited space.
Concrete Tanks Can Crack
Concrete is strong, but it is not flexible.
Ground movement, poor installation, uneven settling, temperature changes, shrinkage, or structural stress can create cracks. Small surface cracks may not always cause a serious problem, but larger or moving cracks can allow water to leak out or groundwater to enter.
Leaks are particularly important in buried rainwater tanks. Incoming groundwater can carry soil, microbes, or other contaminants into stored water.
Cracks near pipe penetrations and fittings can also develop if the plumbing moves independently of the tank.
Regular inspection is important where tank surfaces are accessible.
Repairs Can Be Difficult
Repairing a concrete tank is usually more involved than replacing a fitting on a plastic tank.
A repair may require:
- Draining the tank
- Cleaning the damaged area
- Identifying why the crack developed
- Using a repair material suitable for constant water contact
- Allowing the repair to cure
- Checking whether movement is continuing
Simply sealing a visible crack may not solve the problem if the tank is settling or being stressed by surrounding soil.
Entering a large tank can also create serious confined-space hazards. Owners should not enter enclosed tanks unless proper confined-space procedures and equipment are being used. Professional inspection methods are safer for many internal repairs.
Concrete Is Porous
Untreated concrete contains small pores that can absorb and transmit moisture.
Tank construction and waterproofing methods are therefore important. Poorly built tanks can develop damp areas or slow seepage even when there is no obvious large crack.
The internal surface can also become rough over time. Rough surfaces can hold sediment and make thorough cleaning more difficult than with a smooth plastic tank.
Suitable coatings or liners may sometimes be used, but they introduce another maintenance item. Any material that contacts water intended for drinking must be appropriate for that use.
New Concrete Can Affect Water Chemistry
Fresh concrete is alkaline. Water stored in a new concrete tank may initially have a higher pH because of contact with cement-based surfaces.
How much the water changes depends on factors such as:
- Concrete formulation
- Curing
- Tank age
- Water chemistry
- Contact time
- Internal coatings or treatments
This matters most when the stored water will receive further treatment or may eventually be used as drinking water.
Do not assume that storing rainwater in concrete makes it safe to drink. Drinking-water systems require suitable collection, prefiltration, treatment, maintenance, and current laboratory testing based on the contaminants of concern and applicable local requirements.
Cleaning Can Be More Difficult
Sediment eventually collects in most rainwater tanks.
Leaves, roof dust, pollen, insects, and other fine material can pass through collection screens and settle on the bottom. A first-flush diverter can reduce some of this material by directing the dirtiest initial roof runoff away from the tank, but it does not eliminate tank maintenance.
Concrete tanks can be harder to clean because they may have:
- Rough internal walls
- Corners or joints that hold sediment
- Limited access openings
- Large volumes that take longer to drain
- Deep interiors that should not be entered casually
A properly designed low-level drain, accessible inspection opening, and prefiltration system can make maintenance easier.
Concrete Tanks Are Difficult to Move
A concrete tank should normally be considered a permanent part of the property.
Examine recommended slab thickness for a water tank to compare usable tank volume for projected consumption between storms.
Small plastic rain barrels and some above-ground storage tanks can be repositioned when a garden layout or plumbing system changes. Concrete tanks generally cannot.
This can become a disadvantage if you later need to:
- Expand a building
- Change driveway access
- Move irrigation equipment
- Redesign the rainwater collection system
- Install different underground utilities
Good placement planning is therefore especially important before construction begins.
Pipe Connections Need Careful Planning
Connections through concrete walls must be installed correctly.
A rainwater tank may need connections for:
- Roof-water inlet
- Overflow
- Pump suction
- Gravity outlet
- Drain
- Vent
- Level sensor
- Backup water supply
Pipe penetrations can become leak points if they are poorly sealed or subjected to movement.
The overflow also needs enough capacity to safely carry excess water away when the tank is full. Water should not be allowed to collect around the tank foundation if it could cause erosion, soil movement, or unwanted pressure on a buried structure.
Underground Concrete Tanks Have Extra Risks
Concrete is commonly chosen for underground storage because it can resist soil pressure when properly designed. However, buried tanks also introduce additional concerns.
These include:
- Excavation hazards
- Groundwater pressure
- Soil settlement
- Difficult leak detection
- Harder access for repairs
- Loads from vehicles or structures above the tank
An underground tank must be designed for the actual site conditions. A tank that is suitable for one burial depth or surface load may not be suitable for another.
Excavation and structural design are areas where a simple DIY project can become unsafe quickly.
Freezing Conditions Can Stress the System
Concrete itself can tolerate cold climates when it is properly designed and installed, but the overall rainwater system still needs freeze protection.
Problems often occur around:
- Exposed pipes
- Valves
- Pumps
- Tank fittings
- Overflow lines
- Shallow underground plumbing
Water trapped in a pipe or fitting can expand when it freezes and cause damage.
Climate planning should focus on the complete system, not just the tank wall.
Concrete Tanks Do Not Solve Water-Quality Problems
A concrete tank is only a storage container. It does not remove contamination from roof runoff.
Rainwater can carry material from:
- Roofing surfaces
- Gutters
- Bird and animal droppings
- Dust
- Smoke and air pollution
- Leaves and organic debris
For garden irrigation, the required water quality may be fairly simple to manage. Household uses may require more treatment and separation from drinking-water plumbing.
If rainwater will be used for drinking, the decision should be based on the whole collection and treatment system rather than the tank material alone. Suitable source control, prefiltration, treatment stages, current laboratory testing, maintenance, and local requirements all matter.
When a Concrete Tank May Still Make Sense
Despite these disadvantages, concrete can be a practical choice for some large systems.
It may be worth considering when:
- A permanent tank is acceptable
- Large storage capacity is needed
- The site has suitable access
- The foundation can be properly prepared
- Underground installation is planned
- Professional construction is available
- Long-term inspection and repair access can be maintained
For a small garden system or a location where the tank may need to be moved later, a lighter tank material may be easier to work with.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do concrete water tanks crack easily?
A properly designed and installed concrete tank should not normally develop major cracks, but cracking is possible. Uneven settlement, shrinkage, ground movement, poor construction, and structural stress can all contribute. Cracks that leak or continue to grow should be professionally assessed.
Are concrete tanks safe for drinking water?
Concrete can be used in systems that supply drinking water, but the tank alone does not make rainwater potable. Potable means safe for drinking. The complete system must use suitable materials, appropriate treatment, regular maintenance, current laboratory testing, and comply with applicable local requirements.
Can concrete tanks leak?
Yes. Leakage can occur through cracks, joints, pipe penetrations, or poorly constructed surfaces. Some problems may appear as slow seepage rather than an obvious leak.
Does a concrete tank change the pH of water?
New concrete can increase the pH of stored water because cement-based materials are alkaline. The effect usually depends on the tank age, construction, water chemistry, and any internal treatment or coating.
Are concrete tanks difficult to clean?
They can be. Their large size, rough surfaces, accumulated sediment, and limited access may make cleaning more difficult than in smaller smooth-walled tanks. Tank entry can also be dangerous and may require professional confined-space procedures.
Can a concrete water tank be moved later?
Usually not easily. Concrete tanks are extremely heavy and are generally treated as permanent installations. Tank location should therefore be planned carefully before construction or placement.
Are concrete tanks suitable for underground rainwater storage?
They can be, provided the tank is designed for burial and the specific soil, groundwater, burial depth, and surface loads at the site. Underground installation should not be assumed safe simply because the tank is made from concrete.
