As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
The safest way to tell if water is contaminated is to test it for the contaminants that may be present. Water can look, smell, and taste normal while still containing harmful germs or chemicals. A bad smell, unusual color, cloudiness, or sudden taste change can warn you that something is wrong, but clear water is not proof that it is safe.
This matters even more with collected rainwater. Roof runoff can pick up bird and animal droppings, dirt, smoke particles, roofing chemicals, metals, and other contamination before it reaches your tank.
Signs That Your Water May Be Contaminated
Check for changes in the water and in the system supplying it.
Possible warning signs include:
- A new or strong smell
- Unusual color
- Cloudy or murky water
- Floating particles
- Slime or heavy algae growth
- An oily film
- An unusual chemical or fuel smell
- A sudden change in taste
- More sediment than usual
- Animal droppings or dead animals near the collection area
- Floodwater entering a well, tank, or cistern
- Sewage or septic problems nearby
- A chemical or fuel spill near the water source
- Several people developing stomach illness after using the same water
A change in taste, smell, or appearance is a reason to investigate and test. But it does not tell you exactly what the contaminant is.
Some harmless minerals can make water smell or stain fixtures. At the same time, dangerous contaminants can produce no noticeable change at all.
Clear Water Can Still Be Contaminated
This is one of the most important things to understand about water quality.
You usually cannot see:
- E. coli and other bacteria
- Viruses
- Many parasites
- Nitrate
- Lead
- Arsenic
- Many pesticides
- Many industrial chemicals
Because of this, a glass of clear, odorless water cannot be judged safe simply by looking at it.
CDC specifically advises against relying on appearance, taste, or smell to decide whether water is safe.
How to Test Water for Contamination
Testing should match your water source and how you plan to use the water.
Water used for drinking, cooking, brushing teeth, or other uses where it may be swallowed needs much closer attention than water used only for non-potable jobs such as washing tools.
Potable means water considered suitable for drinking. Non-potable water is water that is not intended for drinking.
Laboratory testing
For water that may be consumed, a qualified drinking-water laboratory is usually the most useful way to confirm contamination.
A laboratory can test for specific substances instead of trying to judge overall "purity."
Depending on the system, testing may include:
- Total coliform bacteria
- E. coli
- Nitrate or nitrite
- Lead and other metals
- pH
- Total dissolved solids
- Chemicals associated with nearby land use
- Other contaminants recommended by the local health authority
EPA recommends using a certified laboratory for drinking-water testing.
Do not simply order every test available. Tell the laboratory where the water comes from and what might have contaminated it. That helps determine what should actually be tested.
Home water test kits
Home test strips and kits can be useful for checking certain individual water characteristics. Their usefulness depends on what the kit measures and how accurately it measures it.
A home test cannot automatically tell you that water is safe.
For example, a kit might test:
- pH
- Hardness
- Nitrate
- Chlorine
- Iron
- Certain bacteria
A result for one parameter says nothing about contaminants the test does not measure.
If drinking-water safety is in question, laboratory testing is a better basis for making decisions.
TDS meters
A total dissolved solids, or TDS, meter measures the amount of dissolved material that affects the electrical conductivity of water.
It can help you notice changes in water or compare water before and after some treatment processes.
It cannot tell you whether water contains harmful bacteria, viruses, parasites, pesticides, or many individual chemicals.
A low TDS reading therefore does not mean water is safe to drink.
How to Check Collected Rainwater
Rainwater needs special attention because contamination can enter at several points between the sky and your tap.
CDC notes that even apparently clean rainwater can contain harmful germs and chemicals.
Inspect the roof and gutters
Look for contamination that could wash into the tank, including:
- Bird or animal droppings
- Leaves and decaying plant material
- Heavy dust
- Moss
- Roof-treatment chemicals
- Construction debris
- Corroding metal
- Damaged gutters
- Standing dirty water
Roof and gutter materials can also affect water quality. Metals and other substances may enter runoff from some roofing, gutter, piping, or storage materials.
Check the first flush system
A first flush diverter sends away the first portion of roof runoff at the beginning of a rain event.
That first runoff often carries a larger load of dirt, droppings, dust, and other material that collected on the roof between rains. CDC recommends considering a first flush diverter as one way to improve collected rainwater quality.
A first flush system improves water quality, but it does not make rainwater automatically safe to drink.
Inspect the tank
Check accessible parts of the tank without entering it.
Look for:
- Open or damaged lids
- Unscreeened openings
- Insect access
- Heavy sediment
- Slime
- Algae
- Animal entry
- Cracks
- Dirty overflow fittings
- Contaminated hoses or pipes
Do not climb inside a cistern or large tank unless the work is being handled with proper confined-space safety procedures. Tanks can present serious fall, air-quality, and entrapment hazards.
Consider recent events
Water quality can change quickly after:
- A long dry period followed by rain
- Very heavy rain
- Flooding
- Roof repairs
- Gutter cleaning
- Tank maintenance
- Wildfire smoke or heavy air pollution
- Animal activity on the roof
- Plumbing repairs
- Chemical use near the collection surface
If rainwater is used for drinking, cooking, or bathing, CDC recommends regular testing for germs and chemicals.
What to Test Rainwater For
Planning around practical steps for testing water without a water tester makes it easier to understand the relevant trade-offs for the upcoming design decision.
There is no single test panel that is right for every rainwater system.
The correct tests depend on the roof, tank, plumbing, local environment, treatment system, and intended use.
For water that may be swallowed, microbial testing is especially important. Indicator tests such as total coliform and E. coli can help identify fecal or sanitary contamination.
Other testing may be needed when there is a reason to suspect:
- Lead or other metals from collection materials
- Agricultural chemicals
- Industrial pollution
- Fuel
- Pesticides
- Other local contaminants
Your local health department or a certified drinking-water laboratory can help choose suitable tests.
Do not assume that passing one bacterial test establishes that every possible chemical or pathogen is absent.
What to Do If You Think Your Drinking Water Is Contaminated
If there is a reasonable chance the water contains harmful contamination, avoid drinking it until you know what you are dealing with.
Use a known safe water supply for drinking, cooking, brushing teeth, and similar uses while the problem is investigated.
Then:
- Identify what changed. Check the source, roof, tank, well, pipes, treatment equipment, and recent events.
- Contact the appropriate authority. For public water, contact the water supplier. For a private well or rainwater supply, contact your local health or environmental department or a qualified drinking-water laboratory.
- Choose tests based on the suspected contamination.
- Correct the source of contamination.
- Use treatment designed for the contaminant found.
- Retest when appropriate before relying on the water for drinking.
Finding contamination does not mean that adding a random filter will solve the problem. Different contaminants require different treatment methods.
Do Not Assume Boiling Fixes Every Problem
Boiling is useful for killing many disease-causing germs.
It does not remove every chemical contaminant.
If water may contain fuel, toxic chemicals, or similar contamination, CDC advises against trying to make it safe simply by boiling or treating it for germs.
That distinction is important with water exposed to a chemical spill, contaminated floodwater, industrial runoff, or unknown substances.
What If the Water Comes From a Private Well?
Private wells require ongoing testing because the homeowner usually has responsibility for water quality.
EPA currently recommends testing private wells every year for:
- Total coliform bacteria
- Nitrate
- Total dissolved solids
- pH
Additional testing may be appropriate based on local conditions. EPA also recommends testing after significant changes such as flooding, construction, well repairs, or noticeable changes in water quality.
Nearby agriculture, septic systems, industrial sites, landfills, fuel tanks, and naturally occurring minerals can change which contaminants should be tested.
What If the Water Comes From a Public Supply?
Public water systems are routinely treated and monitored, but problems can still occur.
If your tap water suddenly changes or you receive a boil-water or do-not-drink notice, follow the instructions from your water supplier or local health authority.
A problem can also occur inside the home after water leaves the public system. Plumbing can contribute metals or other contaminants, and damaged or improperly connected plumbing can create additional risks.
If only one faucet has a problem while the rest of the house is normal, inspect that fixture and its nearby plumbing. If the change affects the entire home, check with the water supplier.
How Often Should Rainwater Be Tested?
There is no universal schedule that covers every rainwater system and use.
CDC advises testing rainwater regularly for germs and chemicals when it is being used for drinking, cooking, or bathing. CDC also advises testing private rainwater and well supplies at least annually when they are used as drinking-water sources.
You may need additional testing after an event that could change water quality.
Examples include:
- Flooding
- Major tank contamination
- Roof replacement
- New collection materials
- Treatment-system failure
- Animal entry
- A nearby spill
- A major unexplained change in smell, color, or taste
The testing schedule should be part of the whole water-safety plan rather than something done only when the water looks dirty.
A Filter Does Not Prove Water Is Safe
Filters are designed for specific jobs.
A sediment filter may remove particles but do little about dissolved chemicals or microorganisms. A carbon filter may reduce certain chemicals and odors but is not automatically a complete microbial treatment system. UV treatment can address susceptible microorganisms when correctly sized, installed, supplied with suitable water, and maintained, but it does not remove chemical contaminants.
Treatment equipment should therefore be selected after identifying the water-quality problem.
CDC recommends testing the water and choosing treatment that specifically addresses the germs or chemicals of concern.
For drinking-water use, think of treatment as a system rather than a single device. Collection quality, prefiltration, treatment stages, maintenance, current water testing, and applicable local requirements all matter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can contaminated water look completely clean?
Yes. Harmful germs and many chemicals do not change the water's color, smell, or taste. Testing is the reliable way to investigate drinking-water safety.
Does bad-smelling water mean it is dangerous?
Not necessarily. Some harmless substances can create strong smells, while dangerous contaminants may have no smell at all. A new or significant odor is still a good reason to investigate and test the water.
Can I use a TDS meter to tell if water is safe to drink?
No. A TDS meter measures dissolved material indirectly through conductivity. It cannot determine whether water is free from harmful bacteria, viruses, parasites, or specific toxic chemicals.
How can I tell if rainwater in my tank is contaminated?
Inspect the roof, gutters, first flush system, tank, screens, and plumbing for possible contamination, but do not rely on inspection alone. If the water will be consumed or used for other higher-risk purposes, appropriate laboratory testing is needed.
Will boiling contaminated water make it safe?
Boiling can kill many germs, but it does not solve every chemical contamination problem. Water suspected of containing fuel or toxic chemicals should not be treated as safe simply because it has been boiled.
What water tests should I order?
The tests should match your water source and possible contamination. Common concerns include microbial indicators such as total coliform and E. coli, nitrate, metals, and locally relevant chemicals. A certified drinking-water laboratory or local health department can help select the correct tests.
Does passing a bacteria test mean my water is completely safe?
No. A bacteria result only addresses the organisms or indicators covered by that test. It does not establish that pesticides, metals, nitrate, industrial chemicals, or every possible pathogen are absent.
